April 19


The Pros and Cons of Solar Tracking Technology

By hacheng1@gmail.com

April 19, 2023

In this comprehensive article, we will explore the world of solar tracking technology, diving into its definition, basic concept, and various types of solar trackers. We will weigh the pros and cons of this technology, comparing it to fixed solar panels to help you make an informed decision for your solar energy needs. Furthermore, we’ll provide guidance on choosing the right solar tracker and discuss the future developments in this field, including advanced control algorithms, machine learning, and integration with energy storage solutions. So, read on to gain valuable insights and knowledge about this innovative and ever-evolving technological domain.

Definition and Basic Concept of Solar Tracking Technology

Solar tracking technology is a system that continuously orients solar panels or other solar collectors towards the sun to maximize the energy conversion efficiency of the solar installation. It is designed to follow the sun’s apparent path as it moves across the sky, ensuring that the collectors remain perpendicular to the sunlight during the entire day, providing a more direct exposure to solar radiation.

Solar trackers can significantly increase the amount of solar energy collected and decrease the amount of land needed for solar installations. They are especially useful in places where access to land is limited or where the cost of land is high. The main goal of solar tracking technology is to enhance energy production, usually by 20 to 45%, compared to fixed-tilt systems without tracking capabilities.

Types of Solar Trackers

The two main types of solar trackers are single-axis and dual-axis trackers. Each category has multiple designs and subtypes that vary based on factors such as region, climate, and usage. The choice between single and dual-axis trackers usually depends on the installation size, the local climatic conditions, and the type of solar technology used.

Single Axis Trackers

Single-axis trackers have one axis of rotation, generally oriented in a north-south direction, following the sun’s movement from east to west throughout the day. Depending on the design, they can either be tilted or placed horizontally. Single-axis trackers can be further classified into four main types:

  1. Horizontal Single Axis Tracker (HSAT): As the name suggests, these trackers have a horizontal axis of rotation. The solar panels are installed parallel to the ground, and the tracker rotates them around the single axis in a single-plane motion. HSATs are most effective at low latitudes where the sun’s daily path is relatively horizontal.
  2. Tilted Single Axis Tracker (TSAT): These trackers possess a tilted axis of rotation, with the solar panels installed at an angle to the ground. TSATs provide improved tracking accuracy in higher latitudes, where the sun’s path is more inclined.
  3. Vertical Single Axis Tracker (VSAT): These trackers feature a vertical rotational axis and are suitable for high latitudes, especially in colder climates where snow accumulation is a concern. With a vertical orientation, the solar panels can easily shed snow and maintain efficient energy production.
  4. Polar-Aligned Single Axis Tracker (PSAT): These trackers have an axis of rotation aligned with the Earth’s axis of rotation, replicating the polar alignment necessary for astronomical tracking. PSATs provide precise solar tracking and are most efficient at high latitudes.

Dual Axis Trackers

Dual-axis trackers have two axes of rotation, one for azimuth (horizontal) motion and the other for elevation (vertical) motion. These trackers enable the solar panels to follow the sun’s movement more precisely throughout the day and throughout the year. Dual-axis trackers can be further classified into two main types:

  1. Azimuth-Elevation (Az-El) Dual-Axis Tracker: These trackers use two orthogonal axes of rotation, with one axis parallel to the ground and the other perpendicular. The system ensures that the solar panels maintain the optimal angle relative to the sun throughout the day and the year, providing maximum energy production.
  2. Tip-Tilt Dual-Axis Tracker (TTDAT): These trackers have a similar performance to Az-El trackers but utilize a different rotational mechanism. The tip-tilt design pivots the solar panel around two axes simultaneously, maintaining their optimal orientation relative to the sun.

While dual-axis trackers offer a considerable increase in energy production compared to single-axis trackers, they also come with higher costs and maintenance requirements. The choice between single and dual-axis trackers depends on project-specific factors, such as budget, location, and efficiency requirements.

Pros of Solar Tracking Technology

Higher Energy Output

One of the most significant advantages of solar tracking technology is its ability to produce higher energy outputs when compared to fixed-position solar panel systems. A solar tracker’s primary purpose is to follow the sun’s movement throughout the day, adjusting the angle and position of the solar panel to achieve maximum sun exposure. This enables the solar module to receive the highest possible amount of sunlight, significantly increasing the energy output. Studies have revealed that solar trackers can produce around 25-45% more electricity compared to fixed-tilt systems.

Maximizing Sun Exposure

By allowing solar panels to follow the sun’s movement throughout the day, solar tracking technology maximizes sunlight exposure. This ensures that the solar panel’s surface is always perpendicular to the sun’s rays, allowing the system to absorb the optimal amount of sunlight at any given time. As a result, solar tracking systems can maintain a high energy output throughout the day, reducing the effects of shading and allowing for increased energy generation during morning and evening hours.

Improved Efficiency and Performance

Solar tracking systems also help to improve the overall efficiency and performance of solar panels. By continuously maintaining the solar panels at the optimal angle, trackers allow these systems to operate more efficiently, which helps to increase the overall energy production. Additionally, solar trackers can also help to reduce operational challenges and maintenance issues that arise due to dust and dirt accumulation, as the constant movement helps to reduce the buildup of debris on the solar module’s surface.

Adjustable to Different Geographical Locations

Another advantage of solar tracking technology is its ability to adapt to different geographical locations with varying sun patterns. Trackers can adjust their angles and positions according to specific regional solar conditions, allowing for maximum energy production regardless of the installation site. This can be particularly beneficial for locations where the sun’s trajectory changes throughout the year or areas experiencing irregular daylight patterns.

Scalability and Flexibility

Solar tracking systems offer remarkable scalability and flexibility, making them suitable for diverse applications ranging from residential rooftop installations to large-scale utility solar farms. This technology can be easily tailored according to specific needs, preferences, and space requirements; the modular design allows for the simple addition or removal of individual solar trackers to accommodate different project sizes. Moreover, solar tracking systems can be integrated with energy storage technologies, offering a comprehensive and reliable solution for consumers.

Reduced Payback Period for Solar Investments

Although the initial cost of a solar tracking system may be higher compared to fixed-tilt installations, the increased energy production can significantly reduce the payback period for solar investments. The increased energy output translates to higher financial returns, as there is more electricity available for consumption or sale to the grid. Over time, the additional revenue generated by solar tracking systems can offset the higher initial costs, making it a more financially attractive option in the long term.

In summary, solar tracking technology offers numerous advantages, including higher energy output, maximizing sun exposure, improved efficiency and performance, adaptability to various geographical locations, scalability and flexibility, and reduced payback periods for solar investments. These benefits make solar tracking systems an attractive option for both residential and commercial applications, promoting sustainable and renewable energy alternatives on a wider scale.

Cons of Solar Tracking Technology

Initial Cost and Investment

One of the major disadvantages of solar tracking technology is the high initial cost and investment required for installation. The solar panels, tracking system, and other hardware components can significantly increase the total cost of a solar energy system compared to a traditional fixed-tilt system. Moreover, specialized installation services are required for solar tracker systems, which can add to the installation costs. The need for additional permits, licenses and regulatory compliance can also increase the overall project budget, making it difficult for individual homeowners and companies to invest in solar tracking technology.

Maintenance and Reliability

Solar tracking systems require regular maintenance due to the presence of moving parts, such as motors, gears, and sensors. These tracking mechanisms are prone to mechanical failure, which can lead to a decrease in the performance efficiency and power output of the solar panels. Frequent inspections and replacement of damaged components are needed to maintain the effectiveness of the tracking system over time, which can be a time-consuming and costly process. Moreover, reliability issues associated with the tracking system can result in the downtime of the solar energy system, affecting its overall productivity and return on investment.

Increased Land Requirements

Solar tracking technology requires increased land usage compared to fixed-tilt solar systems, as the solar panels need ample space to move and track the sun. This leads to a decreased energy density (amount of energy produced per unit of land), limiting the feasibility of solar tracking systems in densely populated or urban areas. The increased land requirements also impact the land’s ecosystem and biodiversity, as the installation of solar trackers might lead to changes in soil composition, water drainage structures, and habitat destruction for certain species of flora and fauna.

Complexity of Installation and Planning

Installing solar tracking systems is a complex process involving thorough planning, specialized expertise, and advanced engineering solutions. The location, type, size, and slope of the site need to be considered, along with the local climate, shading, and geographical constraints. Additionally, the selection of the suitable type of tracking system (single-axis or dual-axis trackers) and the determination of the optimal tracking algorithm for the specific installation site, add to the complexity of the project. The need for grid connection, energy storage devices, and other auxiliary equipment further complicates the installation process, requiring specialized knowledge and skills to ensure functionality and safety.

Power Consumption and Efficiency Losses

Solar tracking technology consumes additional power for operating the tracking motors, sensors, and control systems. This extra power consumption reduces the net energy output and efficiency of the solar energy system, particularly in regions with low sunlight levels. Moreover, solar tracking systems can experience efficiency losses due to factors such as snow or dust accumulation on the solar panel surfaces, adverse weather conditions, and mechanical inefficiencies in the tracking mechanisms which might impede smooth tracking of the sun’s path.

Environmental Impact and Material Usage

Solar tracking systems have a higher environmental impact and use larger amounts of materials compared to fixed-tilt systems. The production of tracking systems requires metals, plastics, and electronic components, which have their respective environmental footprints associated with mining, manufacturing, and transportation processes. Additionally, end-of-life treatment and disposal of these materials can contribute to pollution and landfill waste. Furthermore, due to their large-scale land requirements, solar tracking systems can necessitate deforestation, land clearing, and habitat destruction, posing a challenge to the preservation of the environment and biodiversity.

Comparing Solar Tracking Technology with Fixed Solar Panels

Energy Production and Efficiency

One of the primary differences between solar tracking systems and fixed solar panels is the efficiency in energy production. Solar tracking systems are designed to follow the sun’s movement throughout the day, thereby maximizing the amount of sunlight that can be converted into usable electricity. In contrast, fixed solar panels are stationary and often face a specific direction, such as south or west, which limits their energy production potential.

The higher efficiency of solar trackers can translate to an increased energy production, often ranging from 20% to 45% more than their fixed counterparts. This is because solar trackers can maintain a perpendicular angle to the sun, ensuring that sunlight strikes the solar panel surface optimally throughout the day. Fixed panels, on the other hand, typically receive direct sunlight during peak hours in the morning or afternoon, producing a lower average output across the day.

However, it should be noted that the efficiency and energy production advantages of solar trackers may vary depending on the location and climate. In regions with more consistent and abundant sunlight, the benefits of solar tracking systems can be more pronounced, while the difference may be less significant in areas with variable or limited sunlight.

Cost and Return on Investment

Given the higher energy production potential, solar tracking systems can offer a faster return on investment (ROI) compared to fixed solar panels, despite their higher initial costs. Solar trackers, especially those with more complex tracking mechanisms, are generally more expensive than fixed panels due to the additional hardware and control systems required for tracking the sun.

The cost difference between solar trackers and fixed systems may vary based on factors such as the size of the installation, the type of tracker used, and any local financial incentives that may be available for solar projects. It may also be possible to reduce the initial investment in solar trackers by opting for less complex designs, such as single-axis trackers, which offer a good balance between cost and efficiency improvements.

Despite the higher initial costs, solar trackers can generate more revenue in the form of greater energy production and improved grid connection credits, resulting in a potentially faster ROI. This is especially true in areas with consistent and ample sunlight, as the benefits of solar trackers will be more evident and significant.

Maintenance and Longevity

Maintenance is a crucial factor when comparing solar trackers with fixed solar panel systems, as the former’s added complexity can result in higher maintenance needs. The moving parts in solar trackers, including motors, bearings, and control systems, require regular inspection, cleaning, and lubrication to ensure smooth operation and prevent premature wear and tear.

In contrast, fixed solar panels have very few moving parts, leading to lower maintenance requirements and reduced risk of component failure. This can result in cost savings for the system owner over time, especially when considering the potential for unexpected breakdowns or repairs.

Additionally, the extra components in solar trackers may reduce their overall lifespan compared to fixed systems. While most solar panels are rated to last for 25 to 30 years, tracking systems may have a shorter lifespan due to wear and tear on their moving parts.

Installation and Spatial Requirements

Finally, it is important to consider the installation and spatial requirements for both solar tracking systems and fixed solar panels. Solar trackers often require more space for installation than fixed systems, as they need room for the tracking mechanism to rotate and avoid shading adjacent panels. This could be a limiting factor in the installation of solar trackers in areas with limited available space, such as urban rooftops.

Conversely, fixed solar panels can be closely installed together and are often easier to implement in restricted locations, such as residential rooftops or small ground-mount systems. Another advantage of fixed solar panels is their simplified installation process, which often requires less specialized expertise and reduces the risk of delays or unforeseen issues during construction.

In summary, selecting between solar trackers and fixed solar panels depends on the balance between the higher energy production and ROI potential offered by tracking systems and the lower initial investment, maintenance, and installation complexity of fixed solar systems. Factors such as location, climate, available space, and maintenance needs should all be considered when making this decision.

Choosing the Right Solar Tracker for Your Needs

Solar trackers are devices that automatically move photovoltaic panels to follow the movement of the sun, maximizing the solar panels’ energy output. Selecting the right solar tracker for your needs depends on several factors, including your solar energy goals, site conditions and geographical factors, cost and investment considerations, and the availability of quality solar tracker products.

Assessing Your Solar Energy Goals

Before choosing a solar tracker, it is crucial to determine your solar energy goals. You may consider a solar tracker if you want to:

  1. Maximize Energy Production: Solar trackers can increase energy yield by ensuring panels stay oriented correctly toward the sun, capturing more light than fixed-tilt systems.
  2. Minimize the Solar System’s Size: By using a solar tracker, you can potentially reduce the number of panels needed to achieve your energy goals during space-constrained installations.
  3. Achieve Peak Demand Savings: Solar trackers can help produce more energy during peak demand periods, contributing to reducing utility costs.

Once your goals are clear, it will be easier to identify the solar tracker that best suits your project, taking into account other factors like site conditions and costs.

Evaluating Site Conditions and Geographical Factors

The site conditions and geographic factors heavily influence solar tracker selection. Here are some elements to consider:

  1. Sunlight Exposure: An area with high annual solar radiation, commonly measured as a daily average of kilowatt-hours per square meter (kWh/m2/day), is a suitable location for solar tracking systems. This will ensure enough sunlight to maximize the benefits of the tracking system.
  2. Land Availability and Topography: Solar trackers occupy more land than the fixed-tilt systems, so consider if there is enough space for the tracking system installation. Steep slopes and uneven terrain may influence the solar tracker selection to function correctly.
  3. Climate: Different solar trackers have different tolerance levels to various climate conditions. Some trackers are more suitable for snowy regions, while others work better in hot, arid landscapes.
  4. Wind Loads: Solar tracker installations may be more vulnerable to wind loads than fixed-tilt systems. Ensure that the tracking systems are compatible with the wind loads in your region.

Considering these site-specific factors will lead you to the most appropriate solar tracker for your solar energy system.

Cost and Investment Considerations

The cost of a solar tracker varies based on different factors. Therefore, evaluating the return on investment (ROI) becomes essential. Points to consider include:

  1. Tracker Cost: Analyze the different options in the market and compare the initial investment, as solar trackers are generally more expensive than fixed-tilt systems.
  2. Energy Yield Increase: Estimate the percentage of energy yield increase expected from using a solar tracker compared to a fixed-tilt system.
  3. Maintenance Costs: Solar trackers may have higher maintenance costs due to their moving parts. Factor the costs of regular maintenance and potential repairs when calculating the ROI.
  4. Reduced System Size (if applicable): If the use of a solar tracker allows for a smaller system size, consider the cost savings in the calculation, as fewer panels and balance-of-system components may be needed.

Balancing these cost factors will help you make an informed decision regarding the investment in a solar tracker.

Availability of Quality Solar Tracker Products

Finally, the availability of quality solar tracker products plays a crucial role in your selection process. Take the following aspects into account:

  1. Reputation and Reliability of Manufacturers: Research the solar tracker manufacturers on the market and their products’ durability, reliability, and quality. Collecting data through case studies, reviews, references, and industry peers will help you form an informed opinion.
  2. Warranty: Evaluate the warranty offered by the manufacturers, the scope of coverage, and the duration of the warranty period. A longer warranty period can be an indicator of higher product quality.
  3. Customer Support and After-sales Services: Make sure the manufacturers provide adequate after-sales support, including installation guidance, troubleshooting, and maintenance services. The effectiveness of their customer support in maintaining optimal tracker performance should be factored into your decision-making process.

By considering your solar energy goals, site conditions, costs, and the availability of quality solar tracker products, you can make an informed choice on the most suitable solar tracker for your needs. The right solar tracker will ensure the maximum potential of your solar energy investment, delivering optimal performance and value.

Future Developments in Solar Tracking Technology

Solar tracking technology has seen significant improvement and adoption in recent years, thanks to the continuous improvement in efficiency and reduction in costs. Future developments in this field aim to make solar tracking technology even more efficient, reliable and versatile. Some of the areas where advancements are expected include advanced control algorithms and machine learning, lightweight and durable materials, integration with energy storage solutions, and modular and customizable tracker systems.

Advanced Control Algorithms and Machine Learning

As software and algorithms become more sophisticated, solar tracking technology is expected to benefit greatly from these advancements. Improved control algorithms will enable solar trackers to make smarter decisions and respond more quickly to changes in light conditions. This translates to greater efficiency and productivity of the solar panels, ultimately resulting in higher energy generation.

Incorporating machine learning into solar tracking systems can further enhance their accuracy and responsiveness. Solar trackers can be trained to predict and adapt to changing weather conditions, sun angles, and various other factors that influence the efficiency of solar energy collection. Machine learning can also help increase the life span of the tracking system components by predicting potential issues and suggesting preventative maintenance measures.

Lightweight and Durable Materials

The efficiency of a solar tracking system is closely related to the materials used in its construction. Over the years, there has been significant advancement in lightweight and durable materials such as carbon fiber composites, advanced polymers, and high-strength metals. The utilization of these materials in solar trackers can result in several benefits, including reduced costs and improved reliability due to their lower weight and increased strength.

Lighter and stronger materials can also make it possible to design more complex and efficient tracking systems. For example, dual-axis trackers, which follow the sun’s movement on both horizontal and vertical axes, can greatly increase the overall energy production. However, these trackers are often more costly and challenging to install, and therefore, the use of advanced lightweight materials could minimize these challenges and promote the widespread adoption of dual-axis solar tracking systems.

Integration with Energy Storage Solutions

Energy storage plays a vital role in maximizing the benefits of solar energy production, and there is a growing trend towards integrating solar tracking technology with energy storage solutions. By storing the energy generated during peak sunlight hours, it can be utilized when energy production is low, such as during cloudy days or at night.

Incorporating solar tracking systems with energy storage technologies is expected to result in more efficient and reliable solar power plants. This integration also opens up opportunities for hybrid systems, combining solar tracking technology with other renewable energy sources like wind or hydro power to create a more robust and versatile energy generation system.

Modular and Customizable Tracker Systems

Modular and customizable solar tracking systems will offer enhanced flexibility and ease of installation, making it simpler for solar energy producers, both large and small-scale, to implement tracking technology into their projects. The development of modular and customizable components will allow for a more streamlined construction process, reducing the time and cost required for installation.

As solar tracking technology continues to evolve and grow in popularity, the demand for custom solutions that accommodate unique project requirements is expected to increase. To cater to various installation sizes, topographies, and other factors, solar tracking systems will need to offer a higher degree of customization while maintaining affordability and efficiency.

The combination of these advancements in solar tracking technology will play a crucial role in the ongoing transition towards a more sustainable future. Improved efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and integration with other renewable energy systems will make solar energy even more attractive and accessible, helping to move us closer to a clean and reliable global energy supply.

Frequently Asked Questions on Solar Tracking Technology

1. What are the advantages of using solar tracking technology?

Solar tracking technology offers increased energy production by constantly adjusting solar panels to face the sun. This maximizes exposure to sunlight, resulting in a higher solar energy yield compared to static systems. Additionally, tracking systems can be more space-efficient and potentially reduce the number of required panels.

2. How do the disadvantages of solar tracking technology impact its efficiency?

Although solar tracking systems improve energy yield, they come with drawbacks like higher installation and maintenance costs. Additionally, the mechanical components can be prone to wear and tear, affecting system reliability. Extreme weather conditions may also reduce the efficiency of the tracking system.

3. Are solar tracking systems suitable for all geographical locations?

Solar tracking systems are beneficial in regions with high solar irradiation levels and long sunlight hours. However, the technology might not be as efficient in cloudy or overcast regions. It is essential to evaluate local weather conditions and consider cost-effectiveness before implementing a solar tracking system.

4. Can solar tracking technology be combined with other renewable energy systems?

Yes, solar tracking technology can be integrated with other renewable energy systems, like wind or hydropower, for an efficient hybrid solution. This integration helps maximize energy production while reducing reliance on conventional energy sources, contributing to a sustainable and eco-friendly energy landscape.

5. How does solar tracking technology contribute to environmental sustainability?

By optimizing solar energy production, solar tracking technology maximizes the efficiency of solar panels. This increases the amount of clean, renewable energy generated and helps reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Consequently, it contributes to environmental sustainability by minimizing the need for conventional energy sources.

6. What factors should be considered before installing solar tracking systems?

Before installing solar tracking systems, important factors to consider include geographical location, solar irradiation levels, available space, installation and maintenance costs, and local weather conditions. Thorough evaluation of these factors can help determine the suitability and cost-effectiveness of a solar tracking system for a particular site.


About the author

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Direct Your Visitors to a Clear Action at the Bottom of the Page